(See also this on rating soy products and this on dairy.)
The Cornucopia Institute performs a valuable service for those of us concerned with agricultural sustainability, humane treatment of food animals, organic food production, and protecting small farms and farmers. The organization investigates the conditions under which foods are produced and rates particular brands according to how well they meet the expectations of consumers who are repelled by factory farming.
Its most recent report deals with eggs, and the conclusions are pretty damned disheartening.
Here's the problem:
All organic egg producers claim to be following the federal organic standards, but with different working definitions and viewpoints of what the standards mean. For most consumers and many producers, organic farming means respecting underlying principles of the organic farming movement, such as building soil fertility, maintaining ecological balance, promoting biodiversity, reducing dependence on off-farm inputs,recycling nutrients, and allowing livestock to display their natural instinctive behaviors. For others, especially industrial-scale producers, “organic” appears to be nothing more than a profitable marketing term that they apply to the agro-industrial production system—simply substituting organic feed in their production model and eliminating harmful synthetic inputs, such as pesticides and antibiotics.
The organic standards for livestock, including chickens, include a requirement for outdoor access. But for hundreds of thousands of chickens, "outdoor access" is a sick joke that means only a tiny wooden or concrete porch attached to the massive, crowded henhouse.
There are three routes that an organic egg producer can take.
One is the industrial farming way, which houses thousands upon thousands of chickens in an aviary. They are uncaged, but they are crammed in with no room to move. You need to click on the link above to see a photo of of this to believe how bad it is.
The second route is fixed housing that offers minimal but adequate outdoor access. The third is pasture-based, where the hens are allowed to roam freely and engage in all the instinctual behaviors characteristic of chickens.
Needless to say, industrial farm corporations are fighting all efforts to require and enforce actual access to vegetated outdoor runs.
I'm really appalled that I have no access at any local supermarket to humanely produced eggs. In spring and summer I can buy locally produced free-range eggs, but at other times of the year this isn't possible. The organic eggs offered at the local Meijer are Eggland's Best, which rates only a single egg out of five on Cornucopia's rating scale, or the Meijer brand, which, as a private label, rates the same. Trader Joe's is no better, not that there's a store handily nearby anyway.
(See how your egg brand rates here.)
Please visit the link and see for yourself how these chickens are housed in industrial farms. It's barbaric.
We need to put pressure on the National Organic Standards Board and the USDA to see to it that chickens producing eggs labeled "organic" are housed under better conditions and have meaningful access to the outdoors. Under the industrial farm model, animals are nothing more than production units and are not seen as living beings to be treated humanely.
We should also buy local free-range eggs when we can. The spouse and I have thought for a long time about raising some chickens (or ducks) of our own. It may yet come to that.